Jan 052009

What kind of mind must you have to think that killing your child is the best option? Instead of manning up and paying child support, you kill your child? You are probably wondering what I’m talking about…I read this story on MSNBC.com…here’s an excerpt:

NEW ORLEANS – A man who initially told police gunmen kidnapped his 2 1/2-year-old son was arrested Saturday, accused of committing an “extremely hideous” murder because he was ordered to pay child support, Police Superintendent Warren Riley said.

Danny Platt confessed, told police where to find the child’s body and will be booked with first-degree murder of Ja’ Shawn Powell, Riley said at a news conference.

“He had said he would kill either his wife or his child before he paid child support,” which he recently had been ordered to do, Riley said.

I read this story at least 3 times, trying to understand. Trying to get in the mind of this man who thought that killing this 2-year-old would free him from his responsibility. I thought, “Maybe he didn’t want this child.” And then I thought that maybe he was down and out, not really able to afford child support. But then my rational mind took over and I said that this man was running away from his responsibility and took the bitchass way out. As you can read in the story, he said that he would “either kill his wife or child before he paid child support.” I am shaking my head, and crying within.

He was already missing in this child’s life; according to the story, he had not visited the child until he picked him up on Friday. So as an absentee father, it can only be assumed that he thought that he was devoid of any responsibility. Maybe he thought that he could just move on with his life, without remembering that he had a child somewhere who needed him. And when the mother filed for child support, she gets threatened?

I know that there are women who use child support to juice the father’s of their children, and support themselves. I know that child support rarely goes to the child, and can and has been used for nail appointments, and other things for the mother instead of the child. I’ve seen mothers in grocery stores and in the malls looking like they just stepped out of the hair shop and looking fly from head to toe, while they drag around kids who look like little ragamuffins. And it does make you question why there is no check on why they are letting their children leave the house looking like this, when they don’t.

But does that give a man the right to kill the child, in an effort to eliminate the problem? Again, I go back to the fact that he was not apart of this child’s life. And, if you look at the numbers, it seems as though he was a mere 18-19 years old when this child was born…a child himself. I’m certainly not trying to justify any of his actions, but I’m just trying to make sense of it all. And I think that it is futile, because you can’t make sense out of absurdity.

Too many times the parents of a child make it about them, when it is the child that bears the brunt of the arguing, the dissent, the childish ways of the parents. The child is the one person in this whole thing that deserves the attention. And the child is the one that suffers when parents can’t get their shit together enough to realize that they have been given a gift; no matter the situation that that gift came into…that child was put there to bring something into their lives. And their thinking of that baby as a burden to them, as someone that is in their way is sad.

I’m rambling, mainly because I can’t seem to grasp the concept of this whole thing. And maybe that’s the whole thing. My mind won’t let me understand it. 

On a bigger scale, if our babies cannot trust us to love and protect us, who will they trust? Eventually the cycle of misuse and abuse needs to be broken. Who will be the first to say enough?

Bookmark and Share
  • Symphony
    I can't help you understand this one. I was hoping someone could help me understand. I don't know what his monthly child support was but its not as much as she was responsible for I'm sure. I think its rare that disadvantaged women used child support money to live a glam life. You have rent (if you didn't have a kid you could live in a smaller, cheaper place.) Daycare, child needs and when they get older they need clothes, etc. They want to go on field trips, they want to do things with their friends, they want to participate in activities. For men who have concerns document, take pictures, put the system on the women the way they did it to you. You can't lose your mind about it because 1- you should be out of the money anyway and 2-be concerned enough to fight for full custody. But I'm pretty #2 ain't going to happen with a lot of these guys who whine about child support.


    As far as I'm concerned he didn't want to pay child support nor did he want or know how to be a father. You are right Marv, he didn't want this responsibility.
  • Some things can never be understood.
    Are not meant to be understood.



    If I could understand why he did that there would be something wrong with me.
  • Great post, After reading the story a few days ago I just shut down the computer. This makes totally no sense at all.
    I agree with Symphony but I definitely co-sign Sharon... If I understood this mess something would be wrong with me.
  • No he didn't want this responsibility, Symphony...and this trifling loser was only thinking of himself instead of this baby.
  • You are so right Sharon...
  • Ms. Regina...I keep reading this story and I keep shaking my head...I just can't imagine...I just can't even begin to imagine why.
  • Hello there,


    Anyone who kills is mentally ill... there is NO WAY that anyone can convince me that an emotionally stable person will take another person's life. This man was clearly deranged. I do not blame the mother for any of this but I surely hope that our sistas who are in abusive relationships will TAKE HEED to these news storires... this one... the sister of Jennifer Hudson...there are so many examples out here that should cause an internal alarm to go off within some of the minds of some women who are constantly allowing these unstable, violent men in their lives.



    I am sooo very sad to hear that this poor baby was so horribly treated...to death....



    It is so tragic...
  • You are so right...it is tragic, Rev. Lisa...


    It is my hope also that sistas listen and pay attention to these stories and make whatever changes necessary to climb out of these toxic relationships...
  • Hell is not hot enough for this low life, there is nothing to understand here other than the man is a murderer.
  • John
    I've been hearing a lot about this story lately, since it takes place in my hometown. It makes no sense at all and never will. This man needs to be put in jail for life and never let out.
  • I hear you, Mike...
  • John - It truly doesn't make sense...and I've stopped trying to make sense out of it.


    There is a special place reserved for this person...and where he is going, hell is going to seem like a vacation spot.
  • tom
    Wow, I love your post, you give it like it is. I am glad I found this blog.


    It is sad how people will do anything to get rid of their responsibilities and problems.



    I look forward to reading your blogs
  • Hey Tom...thanks for stopping by!


    This story still blows my mind...and I agree with you; it is very sad that people run away from their responsibilities...this is an extreme case. And I hope a rare one.



    Come back anytime!
  • Hi, really like your blog! Have now bookmarked it and will surely visit again sometime.
blog comments powered by Disqus

© 2007-2010 Conversations With Marva All Rights Reserved -- Copyright notice by Blog Copyright